A first-instance ruling sides with Adore in ongoing exclusive contract dispute with the K-pop group’s management.

A first-instance court has ruled that NewJeans’ exclusive contract with their agency Adore remains valid, signaling a setback for the group amid a prolonged legal battle. The decision comes after more than a year of dispute between the girl group and Adore, centered on the terms and validity of the exclusive agreement. The court’s stance follows Min Hee-jin’s dismissal from Adore and the broader conflict involving Hybe, the group’s major shareholder.

The plaintiffs, the NewJeans members, had argued to terminate the contract on grounds of breach of trust and other issues, asserting that staying with Adore would hinder their activities. But the court found that the grounds cited for termination did not constitute legitimate reasons under the contract. It also noted that Min Hee-jin’s removal did not create a managerial vacuum, and commented on the conduct surrounding the dispute.

In addition, the ruling touched on Min Hee-jin’s behavior, including allegations that she sought to influence public opinion by involving the group’s parents. Adore welcomed the decision and criticized the members’ stance, while the members said activity under Adore would be untenable and pledged to appeal. With roughly four years left on the contract, industry observers say continued litigation could jeopardize NewJeans’ future activities and potential recruitment by new management.

The case remains a developing story as both sides may pursue further legal avenues.